Sentencing study finds disparities you’d expect
But it didn’t delve into why blacks, men in state get more prison time
Wed, Aug 13, 2008 (2 a.m.)
Sun Archives
- Governor gets behind closure of prison (8-12-2008)
- Court gives Vegas killer a new trial (7-31-2008)
- Too many prisoners (4-7-2007)
- Modern urban challenge: bringing up black males (2-11-2007)
Blacks get more prison time than whites, and women receive lighter sentences than men, according to a university study of the state’s court system released Tuesday.
The Grant Sawyer Center for Justice Studies at the University of Nevada, Reno, which examined 10,000 felony convictions in Nevada in 2007, found blacks received “significantly higher” minimum and maximum sentences than white defendants.
The study also found that blacks got significantly higher minimum and maximum sentences for drug trafficking than white or Asian defendants, as well as significantly higher minimum and maximum sentences for drunken driving.
Blacks also received higher minimum sentences than whites for grand larceny and conspiracy and higher maximum sentences than whites for grand larceny, conspiracy and burglary.
Gary Peck, executive director of the American Civil Liberties Union of Nevada, said the study’s findings on their surface “raise red flags.”
“The findings are cause for concern and beg important questions about whether race is playing an impermissible part in the way the criminal justice system works,” Peck said. “There is a massive amount of persuasive social science research indicating that institutional racism continues to plague this country’s criminal justice system.”
Peck said he wanted a chance to more thoroughly review the data used in the study before making any further comments.
Matthew C. Leone, who headed the center’s study, said it was a preliminary one that must “be viewed with caution” because the figures don’t take into account the criminal history of the defendants.
“I’m not going to bet the farm on it,” he told members of the state’s Advisory Commission on the Administration of Justice during a briefing.
James Austin, a consultant to the commission, said comparisons between sentencing patterns for blacks and whites needed further study. Hispanics, he said, were not singled out and were included with the whites in the sentencing study.
The study found other disparities, including that 18 percent of women convicted of a felony ended up in prison, compared with 37 percent of men.
Men, the study found, received significantly higher minimum and maximum sentences overall.
They received higher minimum and maximum sentences for auto theft, burglary, possession of controlled substances, sexual assault and grand larceny, the study found. Men also received higher maximum sentences for drug trafficking and injury to property.
For grand larceny, men received an average minimum term of slightly more than eight months compared with six months for women. The maximum term for grand larceny for men was about 27 months, to about 22 months for women.
Leone and James Richardson, president of the Grant Sawyer Center, told the commission part of the disparity between the sexes may be that men generally have had more prior offenses than women, and more women are considered accessories to crimes committed by men and not as culpable.
Commission member Richard Siegel, the ACLU’s president in Nevada, said the panel understands these findings are “first cut” and that the Grant Sawyer Center would report back with more thorough results.
Siegel said he wants to see how Nevada compares with other states when it comes to differences in gender sentencing. Richardson said it’s generally been the case nationwide that women receive lighter sentences than men.
Leone said the study also showed that Nevada, once believed to have some of the toughest laws on marijuana, now has the most liberal when compared with four other states of similar size and characteristics.
Possession of marijuana of less than one ounce in Nevada is a misdemeanor with a $600 fine. In Arizona, the penalty is 1-18 months in prison; New Mexico, 18 months; Oregon 1-10 years and Utah, a misdemeanor with a one year term.
- Most Read
- Discussed
- Most E-mailed
- CES, porn expo sharing the Vegas stage
- Porn industry feeling pain as expo hits Vegas
- How did CityCenter tower flaws persist?
- Six salmonella cases under investigation in Las Vegas
- M Resort licensing gets OK from gaming board
- Pacquiao favored to beat Hatton in megabout
- Planned dog park meets howls
- Company exec says scaling down is most logical move
- Teen arrested in teacher’s death to be tried as an adult
- Henderson police chief asks to up sales tax for more officers
Blogs
CES 2009
Pro-Obama video earns musician media award
High School Sports Scene
Findlay rolls to 15-0; Rudd liked visit to UNLV
CES 2009
Intel Gets a New Ride
Peripherals for music-band games once again popular at CES
CES a mix of glitterati and gadgets
Charge your devices wirelessly
Politics: The Early Line
Reid's leadership style questioned (5 Comments)
Sports: Upon Further Review
Pacquiao favored to beat Hatton in megabout (2 Comments)
Calendar
- Don McMillian at the Harrah's Improv (8:30 p.m. to 10:15 p.m.)
- CornerStone at Cheyenne Saloon (10 p.m. to 11:59 p.m.)
- Huck Daniels at Jerry's Nugget (10 p.m. to 11:59 p.m.)
- Steel Panther at Ovation (11:30 p.m.)
The Sun
Locally owned and independent for more than 50 years.


Post a comment
Commenting requires registration.
Comments are moderated by Las Vegas Sun editors. Our goal is not to limit the discussion, but rather to elevate it. Comments should be relevant and contain no abusive language. Full comments policy.