Las Vegas Sun

May 5, 2015

Currently: 68° — Complete forecast | Log in | Create an account

Further education cuts spur fear of lawsuits

Adequately funding schools could become constitutional issue

Mo Denis

Mo Denis

The arguments against more cuts in education are blunt: The schools are in bad enough shape. Children are our future. It would be irresponsible.

To that list, Mo Denis, who will be chairman of the Senate Education Committee next year, would add one word: litigation.

If the Legislature cuts too much, he said, “Somebody will probably file a lawsuit and we’re probably going to lose it.”

The lawsuit would likely argue that inadequate funding for schools is unconstitutional. Several such landmark suits, beginning in New Jersey, have been filed across the country and won over the years.

Denis, a computer technician at the Public Utilities Commission, added that many voters think, “With my household budget, if I don’t have any money, I cut back. Why can’t government? If we do that, we get sued. We don’t have a choice.”

And Denis is frustrated that some voters reflexively seek to cut school administrators first.

“Everybody wants accountability, but what does accountability mean?” said Denis, a former head of the Nevada Parent Teacher Association. “You have to generate a report to justify what you’re doing.

“If you have no administrators, you have to have teachers take extra time to fill out paperwork and not use that time to teach.”

The question of how much to cut education is hardly academic.

Fifty-five cents of every dollar of current state spending goes to education — 15 cents for colleges and 40 cents for K-12 (much of it to Clark County).

If, as state budget Director Andrew Clinger projects, the state may fall short as much as $3 billion in a $6.5 billion two-year budget — education cuts will be harsh, even with tax increases.

An assemblyman since 2004, Denis, 49, was born in Brooklyn of Cuban parents. Denis (pronounced “Dennis”) was elected to the Senate this month.

Democrats retain a bare 11-10 majority in the Senate and have held on to a 26-16 majority in the Assembly. Committee chairmen such as Denis — along with Senate Majority Leader Steven Horsford and Assembly Speaker-elect John Oceguera — will shape the budget.

In an interview, Denis also said:

• More than $800 million in federal stimulus money won’t be available in this budget cycle to help close the deficit. “It will be much more difficult this time around.”

• “Everything is on the table,” including keeping one-day-a-month furloughs for state workers, which are set to expire and saved up to $500 million in the last budget cycle. Adding a second furlough day, in effect moving toward a four-day workweek for state government, might save hundreds of millions more.

• The Legislature is committed to the $25 million Millennium Scholarships for higher education, but money for them will have to come from other parts of the budget. Much of the scholarship money comes from taxing cigarettes, and fewer people are smoking.

But it’s litigation that weighs on Denis’ mind.

The landmark case in school-finance litigation is Abbott v. Burke, a protracted lawsuit in New Jersey with key court decisions in 1997 and 1998.

The New Jersey court, followed by courts in other states, defined for state legislatures what is adequate school funding for low-income and high-income school districts.

If the Abbott case is the Brown v. Board of Education of school-finance law, then David Sciarra is its Thurgood Marshall. The lead lawyer in the Abbott case, Sciarra is executive director of the Education Law Center in Newark, N.J.

Nevada is ripe for a lawsuit, Sciarra said, but notes that it is one of only five states in which no case challenging the state’s education finance system has ever been filed.

Nevada ranks 39th among states in the law center’s ranking of what it calls school-finance “justice”.

“Nevada is also regressive,” Sciarra said. “The lower the school is in money, the less likely it is to get money. Nevada is very bleak, very unfair, one of the most unfair in the nation.

“You don’t want to have to deal with this in the courts,” Sciarra added. “It’s time consuming.” Abbott, filed on behalf of inner-city students in 1981, did not reach resolution for 16 years.

If Denis must keep his eye on the big picture, he also has his eye on a smaller picture: His wife became a teacher this year.

Susan Denis has been a stay-at-home mother for 24 years for the couple’s five children, ages 8 to 25. She will be 47 next month and got her teaching credential in May.

Her first weeks were hard, and she thought about quitting, she and her husband said. Instead of 26 kindergartners, she had 33 and several students were disruptive.

“You wouldn’t think seven children would make a difference, but you’re just one person,” she said.

Moreover, as in many other Clark County schools, most of the children are Hispanic and their English is limited. Susan Denis doesn’t speak Spanish. “I’m doing a lot of motioning with my hands,” she said.

Eventually, the class size fell by six students because an extra teacher could be hired with federal stimulus money. And she learned coping strategies.

“I fell back on my background as a mother,” she said. Some of the disruptive students moved to other classes, others she moved closer to her. “There’s a lot of comforting needed because they’re away from their mothers.”

The Denises have always been interested in education.

Mo Denis moved to Las Vegas with his parents and siblings in 1967. His mother was a nanny from Havana and his father a college student from Santiago de Las Vegas (in English, St. James of the Meadows), near Havana. The family settled in a largely Hispanic neighborhood near the Stratosphere.

“I used to say that I got involved to make things better for my children,” Denis said. “But then I realized, when I joined the PTA, that I had to make things better for all children.

“Then, in the Legislature I realized it takes 10 years, sometimes more, to make things better, because it’s so piecemeal.

“So now I’m trying to make it better for my grandkids.”

Join the Discussion:

Check this out for a full explanation of our conversion to the LiveFyre commenting system and instructions on how to sign up for an account.

Full comments policy

Previous Discussion: 6 comments so far…

Comments are moderated by Las Vegas Sun editors. Our goal is not to limit the discussion, but rather to elevate it. Comments should be relevant and contain no abusive language. Comments that are off-topic, vulgar, profane or include personal attacks will be removed. Full comments policy. Additionally, we now display comments from trusted commenters by default. Those wishing to become a trusted commenter need to verify their identity or sign in with Facebook Connect to tie their Facebook account to their Las Vegas Sun account. For more on this change, read our story about how it works and why we did it.

Only trusted comments are displayed on this page. Untrusted comments have expired from this story.

  1. It's long past time to bring "public" education back into the real world. Get back to educating instead of indoctrinating. Teach the basics (the "3 R's") so kids can actually go out into the work force prepared instead of needing remedial work. Open the education system up to real competition by allowing parents to choose the schools their children attend. Get rid of "social promotions." Unshackle teachers from political correctness. Teachers actually want to impart knowledge and not merely be babysitters. Time to use their capabilities to the fullest.

  2. Chunky says:

    He likes what Mr. Jerry Fink wrote in his comment above!

    We don't need new taxes, we need efficiency and to get back to the basics until such time we can AFFORD to spend more on eduction.

    Giving parents a choice is a good idea as well and getting them involved in their child's education is critical. Most home-schooled children Chunky has met are leagues above and beyond their age group in intellect, maturity, manners and attention span!

    Maybe parents should supplement what their children are getting or missing in public schools with a little "face time" instead of outsourcing their kids like you'd outsource your lawn maintenance!

    That's what Chunky thinks!

  3. I predicted this. Add the Courts, the prisons, and the environment to the list of areas that tax cuts will be fought with law suits.

  4. Money is not the problem with education. It's how and where it's being spent. Washington D.C. public schools spend the most money per child and have the worst record when it comes to results. Ms. Rhee was turning that around and, voila, she's toast! She broke the prime rule: Don't mess with the sacred cows! Administrators don't want results; they want perks, pensions and promotions! The kids be damned! Chunky: thank you.

  5. I'm glad the courts may get involved. Republicans have obliterated education in this state by insisting that it constantly be cut even though for years the numbers of students increased and the teachers were paid nothing. Giving parents a choice as to where they will drive their kid to school in the morning does nothing to improve schools that are not doing well; it also ignores the fact that all of our schools in Nevada do poorly compared to the rest of the country. Enough with the Republican idea of wanting to "train workers" as Jerry and Chunky-Wunky desire. I want my tax dollars to inspire teachers and educate future leaders. That will not be accomplished by constant cuts in both public education and higher education.

  6. Some of these comments are totally divorced from reality.

    Having attended CCSD schools for most of my life (thankfully, not for the first year...), my experience tells me that the answer is much simpler than anyone here has said: when an well-educated workforce is in the economic interest of the gaming industry (mining too, maybe), then we'll have one.