Las Vegas Sun

May 4, 2015

Currently: 74° — Complete forecast | Log in | Create an account

Sun Editorial:

In Las Vegas debate, Republican candidates offer a welcome surprise on nuclear waste

In their words

A selection of comments the candidates made during the Republican presidential debate in Las Vegas. The full transcript can be found at CNN's website.

Rep. Ron Paul, R-Texas:

Quite frankly, the government shouldn’t be in the business of subsidizing any form of energy. And nuclear energy, I think, is a good source of energy, but they still get subsidies. Then they assume this responsibility. Then we as politicians and the bureaucrats get involved in this. And then we get involved with which state’s going to get stuck with the garbage.

So I would say, the more the free market handles this and the more you deal with property rights and no subsidies to any form of energy, the easier this problem would be solved.

Former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney:

If Nevada says, “Look, we don’t want it,” then let other states make bids and say, hey, look, we’ll take it. Here’s a geological site that we’ve evaluated. Here’s the compensation we want for taking it. ... Let the free market work. And on that basis, the places that are geologically safe, according to science, and where the people say the deal’s a good one will decide where we put this stuff. That’s the right course for America.

Texas Gov. Rick Perry:

You know, from time to time, Mitt and I don’t agree. But on this one, he’s hit it, the nail, right on the head. ... and, Congressman Paul, you’re correct when it comes to allowing the states to compete with each other. That is the answer to this.

During the Republican debate Tuesday at the Venetian, the presidential candidates were asked whether they support plans to dump the nation’s nuclear waste at Yucca Mountain, 90 miles northwest of Las Vegas.

We weren’t expecting much from the candidates. For years, we’ve heard candidates, supported by the nuclear industry, patronize Nevada on the issue, and Tuesday night it appeared we would hear more of the same. Answering first, former House Speaker Newt Gingrich fit the stereotype: He outlined his support of the project, adding that while in Congress, he worked with Nevada lawmakers to provide time for scientific studies.

In other words: He cares about Nevadans’ views but still wants to make the state a nuclear waste dump. George W. Bush said something similar during the 2000 campaign, pledging to make a decision on Yucca Mountain based on “sound science.” But after Bush took office, sound science took a back seat to politics.

Just when we were about to grab the remote control, CNN anchor Anderson Cooper, the debate moderator, asked Rep. Ron Paul about his opposition to Yucca Mountain.

“I approach it from a states’ rights position,” Paul said. “What right does 49 states have to punish one state and say, ‘We’re going to put our garbage in your state?’ I think that’s wrong.”

Then former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney said he agreed with Paul.

“The idea that 49 states can tell Nevada, ‘We want to give you our nuclear waste,’ doesn’t make a lot of sense,” Romney said. “I think the people of Nevada ought to have the final say as to whether they want that.”

Cooper asked Texas Gov. Rick Perry what he thought.

“You know, from time to time, Mitt and I don’t agree,” Perry said. “But on this one, he’s hit it, the nail, right on the head.”

Wow. We didn’t think we’d ever hear one, much less two, Republican front-runners offer support for Nevada’s opposition.

In some ways, this shouldn’t be a surprise. Conservatives over the past few years have trumpeted the 10th Amendment, which guarantees states’ rights, to try to fight against the federal health care law and other federal issues. But their love for states’ rights has stopped at Yucca Mountain.

For decades, Nevadans have been clear that they don’t want the nation’s nuclear waste, and yet the nuclear industry’s supporters in Washington have ignored the state’s wishes and railroaded plans through Congress.

The nuclear industry’s supporters have treated Nevada like a little child, telling the state it knows what is best. They have dismissed the serious safety and scientific issues that plague the plans and make brash claims. For example, during the debate Gingrich said “most geologists” had found Yucca Mountain suitable and “geologically stable.”

But that argument doesn’t stand up. Yucca Mountain isn’t a solid mountain; it’s a porous volcanic ridge in an area prone to earthquakes. And geologists didn’t pick Yucca Mountain. Politicians did.

Congress cut short a scientific search for a nuclear waste dump in the 1980s, choosing Nevada to be the nation’s nuclear waste dump. Why? Nevada’s congressional delegation didn’t have the clout to stop the plans.

The state has continued its opposition, and the Nevada congressional delegation, led by Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, has diligently worked to cut funding for the project. After he took office, President Barack Obama brought some common sense to the issue, telling the Energy Department to end its work. However, Republican leaders in Congress have continued to push for the project and made an all-out push to revive the moribund and dangerous project.

We hope they were listening to the debate. Nevadans don’t want it, and some of the leading Republicans running for president say Nevada shouldn’t be forced to take it. Republicans in Congress should see the writing on the wall and drop the plan once and for all.

What do you think? Send your thoughts in a letter — no more than 250 words. Include the writer’s name, address and phone number. Anonymous letters will not be considered. E-mail:

Join the Discussion:

Check this out for a full explanation of our conversion to the LiveFyre commenting system and instructions on how to sign up for an account.

Full comments policy

Previous Discussion: 2 comments so far…

Comments are moderated by Las Vegas Sun editors. Our goal is not to limit the discussion, but rather to elevate it. Comments should be relevant and contain no abusive language. Comments that are off-topic, vulgar, profane or include personal attacks will be removed. Full comments policy. Additionally, we now display comments from trusted commenters by default. Those wishing to become a trusted commenter need to verify their identity or sign in with Facebook Connect to tie their Facebook account to their Las Vegas Sun account. For more on this change, read our story about how it works and why we did it.

Only trusted comments are displayed on this page. Untrusted comments have expired from this story.

  1. Interesting what they all said regarding an issue they probably could care less about. The only way they would care about it is if they found out how much money would line their pockets if they encouraged it. The Republican Party, in its entirety, thinks predatory thoughts like that...even at the expense of what people don't want.

    But that's okay, Yucca Mountain Project is not going to happen.

    The fight has been going on for quite a few years and the tide has turned. This "Screw Nevada Campaign" started in the 1980s has lost momentum. Nevada is stronger now politically. We keep fighting them off and make them waste money and time in courts. Eventually, the law suits will fizzle out and when they find out they can't throw it at Nevada, they'll give up. Time is on our side. We can easily afford to wait them out.

    I encourage them to keep trying though. Because that process needs to continue in order for it to sink into their thick heads it's not going to work. And that Nevada decides what is best for it. We are not interested in handling nuclear waste, the most dangerous substance known to mankind. Because if we get saddled with it? It's forever. We cannot accept a burden like that and throw it unfairly on future generations of Nevadans; Nevadans that aren't even born yet. They would curse our graves. Guaranteed.

    Yucca is a pipedream. Take it somewhere else. Bury it in Gingrich's backyard or something if he wants the money that bad.

  2. As long we don`t need new jobs in Nevada, its ok by me!