Las Vegas Sun

April 28, 2015

Currently: 80° — Complete forecast | Log in | Create an account

Sandoval refusing to disclose millions in state agency budget requests


Leila Navidi

Governor Brian Sandoval delivers the keynote address during the Governor’s Conference on Small Business at the Orleans on Friday, November 2, 2012.

Gov. Brian Sandoval's administration is keeping secret millions of dollars in spending requests submitted by state agencies for the next two years, breaking precedent set by prior administrations and possibly violating state law, legislators suggested.

Indeed, even Sandoval held to the practice two years ago, submitting the so-called “items for special consideration” to lawmakers and the public well before releasing his final recommended budget to the Legislature in January.

This year, however, Sandoval has elected to publicly release only the agency requests that fit within strict caps he issued as part of his budget instructions, and not what agencies said they needed to properly operate.

Some of the budget requests being kept under wraps by Sandoval this time include the cost to expand Medicaid, a politically tempestuous decision that would provide thousands of low-income Nevadans additional health care, but have short and long-term costs for the state.

Other agency requests are to restore programs that have been cut since 2008, such as those that help poor families afford child care, according to interviews this fall with state workers.

Many of the requests are likely as banal as new computers and vehicles for state agencies that have been operating under fiscal constraints since the economy took a nose dive in 2007, forcing agencies to scale back.

Still, lawmakers from both parties said they wanted to see an honest accounting from state agencies on the ground, who run the state’s parks, prisons, and programs for the poor and disabled.

“I think legislators and the public should know what the requests are from agencies, what the real needs are,” said Sen. Debbie Smith, D-Sparks, the chair of the Senate Finance Committee. “It puts our staff, and ultimately legislators, at a severe disadvantage to not have that information.”

Sandoval’s top staff would not be interviewed for this article. Agency heads said they have been instructed not to talk about the “items for special consideration.”

Neither the state budget office nor the governor’s office would release total supplemental requests by agencies. Outside experts, though, have estimated Medicaid expansion alone would cost the state tens of millions of dollars in administrative costs over the next two years.

In a statement, budget director Jeff Mohlenkamp said the governor’s office is following the law.

“Since the budget process is very fast-paced and dynamic in nature, we asked agencies to identify potential enhancements that could be considered by the governor in the event that revenues allowed for additional expenditures to be considered,” he said.

Some agency requests, he said, could never be made public.

“These items are not public unless they become part of the governor's budget," he said.

Sandoval, who is up for re-election in 2014, has built a rosy budget narrative heading into next legislative session, where he has promised not to cut K-12 education and to protect social services for the poor, while not raising taxes above their present levels.

Last week, when the Economic Forum issued revenue projections that Sandoval is required to use for his proposed budget, the forecast seemed to be tailor-made for the spending proposals state agencies have already put forth.

The forum projected $5.8 billion in revenue over the next two years. Add to that the $620 million in tax hikes Sandoval wants to extend and the total revenue almost exactly matches the $6.4 billion in spending that agencies have requested.

But that’s because Sandoval's administration issued budget instructions to department heads earlier this year to keep their budget requests under a certain cap.

Sandoval instructed agencies to keep spending requests basically flat, and to include only mandatory increases above the 2011 budget such as utility costs and caseload growth.

But the 2011 budget, passed by the Legislature and signed by Sandoval, hasn’t been without some degree of pain. Services to newborns to 3-year-olds suffering with autism, Down syndrome and other conditions had to be cut because of state budget constraints. Wait times for veterans to get state help to access federal benefits are at eight weeks, after Sandoval’s budget in 2011 did not include two staff positions in Las Vegas. And schools across the state have had to reduce teaching positions and face rising class sizes, while headlines blare about Nevada’s worst-in-the-nation graduation rate.

Sandoval is also constrained on the tax side. He has promised not to raise taxes above their current levels.

Still, the issue of transparency is bipartisan.

At an October legislative hearing, Democratic lawmakers brought up the fact that the additional agency budget requests were not being released.

Sen. Ben Kieckhefer, R-Reno, referred to the possible expansion of Medicaid, the state health insurance for the poor. It’s a provision under the Affordable Care Act which the U.S. Supreme Court said could be optional for states, and a decision Sandoval is still weighing.

“My concern is this: Medicaid expansion has been penciled out, calculated, but if it’s not part of the governor’s budget, (that information) would not be public?” Kieckhefer said. “I have a problem with that.”

Brenda Erdoes, Legislative Counsel for the legislative branch, said the administration had broken with the “historical interpretation of the statute” requiring governors to make public agency requests in October prior to the legislative session.

Mohlenkamp said at the meeting the budget office was complying with the law.

“There could be wish lists — this could go on forever if you say, 'What are things people want that aren’t included in the budget?'” he said. “I don’t think it’s fair to speculate on things that are not in the budget.”

Nevada law says that on Sept. 1, agency budget requests should be transferred to legislative staff. It also says agency budget requests should be made public on Oct. 15.

On Sept. 1, legislative staff agreed to accept an electronic version of the budget from the Sandoval administration, to save on printing costs. At that time, legislative staff had access to the “items for special consideration” in the governor’s executive budget system.

But on Oct. 15, when the agency budgets were supposed to be made public, legislative staff’s access to the special items was shut down.

Smith, the state senator, said: “I think it’s fair to the public, to the taxpayers, that we see what the actual requests are.”

Join the Discussion:

Check this out for a full explanation of our conversion to the LiveFyre commenting system and instructions on how to sign up for an account.

Full comments policy

Previous Discussion: 6 comments so far…

Comments are moderated by Las Vegas Sun editors. Our goal is not to limit the discussion, but rather to elevate it. Comments should be relevant and contain no abusive language. Comments that are off-topic, vulgar, profane or include personal attacks will be removed. Full comments policy. Additionally, we now display comments from trusted commenters by default. Those wishing to become a trusted commenter need to verify their identity or sign in with Facebook Connect to tie their Facebook account to their Las Vegas Sun account. For more on this change, read our story about how it works and why we did it.

Only trusted comments are displayed on this page. Untrusted comments have expired from this story.

  1. I sure hope he is hiding something, it keeps the communists on their toes.

  2. What communists? I see no communists in any position of power here or anywhere else in the United States. Nor do I even see a powerful communist party. We have, in this country, only one major political party, the Democrats. There used to be another party, called the Republicans, filled with bigots who hate the president, because he reminds them of something from Blazing Saddles, more than they love our country. I wish they felt differently because we need more patriots.

  3. The public not knowing what was requested protects puppet Sandoval and his master's plans. NV Government i.e., state and local operate inside a lawless dark vacuum.

    Nevada's famous 3 day notice shows how broken and desperate our dysfunctional non-representative government is removed from doing the people's business in favor of deals for themselves and their powerful friends"

  4. The legislatures response should be a no brainer: DISAPPROVED

  5. The Governor, acting as the chief executive of the state, submits a budget to the legislature. The individual departments can ask for any amount of money but the Governor can limit that department to the money available. The legislature can agree to the budget or change it. It just has to be a balanced budget.

    I have seen my property appraisal for next year. It has gone down again. If this is what the rest of the valley is like, then the city and county is going to have to work with less money, just like the state.

  6. Well if we buy into Obamacare it will cost us multi-millions starting with this budget. DH&HS insists on one full time employee per every XX MEDICAID recipients--to process their applications. And then, they'll want more supervisors and managers. HOWEVER, the State hasn't processed thousands of health-care provider claims from years ago. Sooner or later somebody needs to address this as some providers refuse to treat those on MEDICAID. Now, if we could get them to stop hiring and promoting their pals and significant others, former significants..... and CUT COMPENSATION down to reasonable levels--especially when they "approve" of city, county, and school district budgets--like insisting that EVERY government employee pay half of their retirement contributions.