Las Vegas Sun

July 5, 2015

Currently: 100° — Complete forecast | Log in | Create an account

High-speed rail project beset by political mine fields


Courtesy XpressWest

An artist’s rendering of a train on the XpressWest high-speed rail line.

Things were supposed to be settled by now.

Construction workers were supposed to be digging up corridors, pouring concrete, laying track and otherwise making the country’s first government-endorsed high-speed rail line rise out of the desert between Las Vegas and the Los Angeles exurbs.

On the wings of one project, Southern Nevada’s economy was supposed to be back to work.

But in the years since the XpressWest project (formerly Desert XPress) applied for an industry-backed federal loan to finance the venture, it has run into almost every conceivable political roadblock – and this month, one direct assault.

“The risks to the taxpayer from funding this project are untenable,” Rep. Paul Ryan and Sen. Jeff Sessions, the top-ranking Budget Committee Republicans in their respective chambers, wrote to Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood earlier this month. “We would urge the Administration to reject the XpressWest loan application and to direct its available RRIF funds to more worthy transportation projects.”

It’s the most scathing indictment yet of a project that has suffered from extraordinarily unlucky timing – and the direct attack has at least some of its supporters concerned that the pushback may relegate an already-beleaguered project even further to the back burner.

“I am concerned about it because of the numbers that I’ve seen and the amount of jobs it would create,” said Nevada Sen. Dean Heller, whose staff is speaking to Sen. Majority Leader Harry Reid’s about what could be done to resist the sudden effort to undermine to the project. “It was disappointing that they put that (letter) out there because the funds that are used ... have been funded by the railroad industry for this purpose.”

“It’s more of this Tea Party-driven response,” Reid said. “That is nonsense to hear from the two budget chairs who want to go back to the dark ages on most everything.”

But XpressWest’s main advocates are being cautious about dismissing the bluster from the budget committee Republicans too quickly because they have been down a similar road before.

“At several momentum-gathering points, something appeared, whether it was the election, the (fiscal) cliff, or now the sequester,” said Billy Vassiliadis, lobbyist with R&R Partners, which has been representing the XpressWest venture. “There’s always something that’s a momentum-stopper.”

In theory, lawmakers and lobbyists familiar with ongoing negotiations say the Obama administration is on board with the XpressWest plan.

They are, at present, merely going back and forth about the interest rates and size of the loan. Anthony Marnell, the main force behind the high speed rail venture who has already put up $1.5 billion from private investors, wants an additional $5.5 billion from the Federal Railroad Administration’s Railroad Rehabilitation & Improvement Financing program. The $35 billion federal fund is financed by the railroad industry and has lent money to 33 rail projects since its inception, according to the railroad administration’s website.

Click to enlarge photo

Anthony A. Marnell II is a key figure in the development of XpressWest, the high-speed rail system planned between Las Vegas and Southern California. Marnell is chairman and CEO of the Marnell Companies, a partner in the train project.

The government, meanwhile, is pushing for a somewhat smaller loan, in the $4.5 billion to $5 billion range.

Either way, XpressWest would be the single largest loan disbursed by the program by far. The next-highest loan, made to Amtrak in 2011, was $500 million.

The terms of the loan, which was initially supposed to be awarded in mid-2012, are expected to be settled soon – a fact that partially inspired the letter from Ryan and Sessions.

In light of that letter, however, backers are somewhat concerned that an already-cautious government may become skittish about approving the loan as expected.

“There was anxiety on (the government’s) part, because of Solyndra, and we came out on the heels of that,” said Vassiliadis, who has recently been making near-monthly trips to Washington, D.C., from his base in Las Vegas to meet with railroad administration officials.

Solyndra is a solar cell manufacturing plant that became the unfortunate poster child for the Department of Energy’s renewable energy loan guarantee program when the half-billion-dollar venture went bankrupt. That episode effectively ended the political drive to extend the loan guarantee program, which had backed mostly successful projects, including a hybrid solar power plant in Tonopah.

Critics have voiced Solyndra-esque concerns about the prognosis of XpressWest. Part of the Marnell company’s repayment model for the federal loan is assumption that once the rail line is built, customers will want to buy tickets, estimated at $89 for a round trip. But there are no guarantees.

Questions have also been raised about the viability of the estimated 80,000 jobs that the project would create – enough to knock Nevada’s unemployment rate down by 5 or 6 percent. A study by the Associated Press found that only 722 of the estimated 80,000 jobs would be permanent.

And finally, there is a concern from the government about funding.

XpressWest was initially pitched as a fully self-funded enterprise. But in the post-recession period, backers found there was not as much available private capital for high-speed rail as they had anticipated. That’s why they need the federal loan to meet the $7 billion project cost.

XpressWest officials are certain that once they secure a government loan, they will have the credibility to find more private financiers. The federal government, however, would like to see the rail project pony up more money before it gives the project the green light, Vassiliadis said.

“It’s almost like a chicken and egg,” Vassiliadis said. “If we get the designations, then we can go shop.”

The railroad administration did not return a request for comment.

Nevada lawmakers are maintaining a confident front about XpressWest’s predictions.

“There will be plenty, plenty of traffic,” Heller said. “I’ve driven between L.A. and Las Vegas at times when traffic was pretty heavy. I think it’s something that’s needed.”

“We have such a difficult time getting people back and forth from Southern California to Southern Nevada, and it’s not just to watch the shows in Las Vegas – it’s commerce,” Reid said.

The Nevada delegation has no XpressWest detractors – not even from members whose districts won’t serve as direct hosts for the project.

“I appreciate that this is a government program ... from what I understand, they’re going to be competing for money that’s already there,” said Republican Rep. Mark Amodei, who represents Nevada’s northernmost district. “If they compete successfully for that, then that’s fine with me.”

“Critics armed with partisan math need to get out of the way,” said Democratic Rep. Steven Horsford, whose district covers the swath of the state from North Las Vegas to Amodei’s district. “Neither a senator from Alabama nor a congressman from Wisconsin will derail a Nevada jobs project.”

“There’s no reason we couldn’t actually launch an industry,” Vassiliadis said, further defending XpressWest’s numbers. “There’s all these corridors all over the country ... if we launched the ability to be manufacturers, engineers ... if we can get going, this is an industry.”

But the would-be industry still has to clear a political minefield newly laid by skeptical Republican lawmakers looking for ways to balance the budget – and potentially, to deliver a disappointment to the Senate majority leader, who has repeatedly frustrated their party on fiscal matters.

Considering that, project backers say, the threat is serious enough that the only way to be sure the XpressWest project will prevail is if a higher power helps push the normal process along.

“To go or no go is clearly the decision of someone in the White House,” Vassiliadis said. “I think the president. He would have to do it.”

Join the Discussion:

Check this out for a full explanation of our conversion to the LiveFyre commenting system and instructions on how to sign up for an account.

Full comments policy

Previous Discussion: 10 comments so far…

Comments are moderated by Las Vegas Sun editors. Our goal is not to limit the discussion, but rather to elevate it. Comments should be relevant and contain no abusive language. Comments that are off-topic, vulgar, profane or include personal attacks will be removed. Full comments policy. Additionally, we now display comments from trusted commenters by default. Those wishing to become a trusted commenter need to verify their identity or sign in with Facebook Connect to tie their Facebook account to their Las Vegas Sun account. For more on this change, read our story about how it works and why we did it.

Only trusted comments are displayed on this page. Untrusted comments have expired from this story.

  1. No, it isn't about any of that. Almost everyone in Las Vegas laughs at a train to Victorville! No one needs a train to no where. If this were a viable project today to eliminate traffic, such as the Mag Lev project that was on the table for 25+ years, which Harry Reid backed for 25+ years until his campaign team told him to flip and go to DesertEXpress/ExtprsssWest, we would all get behind it. The only political corruption here is Harry flipping on Mag Lev for this stupid project because his political team also repressents this project. Lets be real. Tony Marnell has to be one of the most important people in Southern Nevada, but I am sorry Tony, this projects makes NO SENSE to anyone but you. I am leaving for LA by car in a few hours. I would NEVER take a train to Victorville and then what? Rent a car in Victorville to LA? My car goes almost as fact as that antiquated train project so I applaud Washington for seeing how stupid this project is. This is another Strip Monorail project...

  2. I don't know about any of you, but I have started a raft of businesses in my lifetime (some succeeded; some failed) and I never asked for government assistance in the form of taxpayer guarantees or bailouts. If this train project is so wonderful, why are its investors asking for taxpayer involvement? Screw the "fat-cats," the "good-old-boys" and their insatiable appetite for others to take the risks while they make a profit either way.

  3. This is a project that will propel Las Vegas as the originator of High Speed Rail. Make no mistake, this project is the future of HSR transportation, and support of intermodal connections between Nevada and California.

    This is historic. This is the next Hoover Dam in terms changing the country transportation needs. Not to mention the new commerce that will develop between Nevada and California.

    President Obama has made it clear that HSR is his number one priority in transportation.

  4. Jeez, boys... This really isn't rocket science. We all know how to get this train back on track... Just make the usual contribution to Harry's election campaign and all this bickering would stop instantly and the plan would proceed as planned...

  5. The problem is that it would be the first train to Victorville before any connecting lines are built from there to population centers. Victorville is a minimum 90 minute drive from LA, and not a destination in itself. Unless the tiny desert town is already a hub for lines from large cities, it would be putting the cart before the horse to spend tax dollars on a train going no further.
    Steve Miller, Former Clark County Regional Transportation Commissioner

  6. Stupid Stupid plan. Hopefully wiser heads in Washington will prevail. I hope Heller doesn't fall for Harry's crap again. It's so transparent that this is for the benefit of Harry's buddies. Build it with private money if it's such a great idea. No problem with that!

  7. What ever happens, it will be the 'children, grandchildren and great grandchildren' who will be looking at those of us now and cursing the day they have no affordable gasoline for their old cars that go nowhere, and can't afford the airline tickets for the reduced number of planes available to more limited locations. The cost of goods will also go up as shipping limitations increase. Standard of living decreases.
    Thanks folks for your forward thinking.

    The leg from LV to Victorville is a part of a Southwest Network, going to many more locations than just LA when completed.

    It is a good time to begin, a time when jobs are needed, and that extends beyond tracks to jobs creating the services and supplies needed.

    Or maybe we should wait for a time when interest rates on loans are even higher, so the cost of needed travel is higher.

    By not using forward thinking, directing money into making war rather than actually helping build our nation's infrastructure, we fall faster from the nest of a first world country.

    I, sadly, won't be here to enjoy something I have enjoyed so much in the past, rail transportation and meeting the wonderful people who also enjoy the same journeys.

    I wonder just how much palm greasing is going on to delay or shelve this project and others. Who will win the fight between electric and oil interests this time?

    Will the northeast corridor be the only high speed rail system in the US? We need a national high speed rail system to begin being built now.

    Of course, our politicians and their entourages don't need to worry about it since they travel free on the tax payers money. All they have to worry about is getting reelected so they can continue living in their yearly golden parachute of power.

    We need more future thinkers.

  8. Privately funded... great. Publicly funded... no go. Construction costs will outstrip estimates by far and so will operating costs. Taxpayers from Hawaii to Maine will be stuck with another big dig they and most others will never ride.

    Vegas to San Diego, San Francisco ... great. LA maybe, the middle of nowhere and a long drive to final destination... another clam bake without the clams.

    Public pipe dreams are just that, smoke that irritates most and satisfies few. And a costly smoke at that. We fly to San Diego frequently for less than it costs to fill my tank and 1/3 of what it costs to drive. Why would I take all day, have to rent a car & take an expensive taxi to change trains for more than the cost to fly?

    Might work for folks with more money than sense but it ranks up there with driving in rush hour traffic when your retired for me.

  9. Sign me up. I can't wait to take an $89 dollar train ride to Victorville then get a $35 dollar a day rent car for a 3 day weekend visit to LA and pay $15 in auto gas rental fuel. $209 dollars for train/rent car versus an $80 dollar gas fill up trip in my car. I'll take paying 2 1/2 times more my current cost to get to LA any day.

  10. The automobile, petroleum and road builders are shaking in their nylons about high speed rail.

    Once the public experiences the SAFETY, peacefulness and dependability of trains they will look forward to national travel on Continental systems.

    Unfortunately, many people are still lamenting the passing of the buckboard.