Las Vegas Sun

July 6, 2015

Currently: 85° — Complete forecast | Log in | Create an account

Nevada schools superintendent resigns, gives no reason



Nevada State Superintendent Jim Guthrie testifies in an education committee at the Legislative Building in Carson City on March 1, 2013. Guthrie told lawmakers that effective teachers trump the issue of class size. Clark County Schools Superintendent Dwight Jones is at left.

Updated Friday, March 29, 2013 | 6:45 p.m.

Jim Guthrie announced his resignation as Nevada superintendent overseeing the state's 17 school districts on Friday.

Guthrie — whose ideas surrounding class size reduction sparked controversy among teachers and legislators recently — did not explain his reason for leaving.

“All I can say is I’m resigning, effective immediately,” Guthrie said when reached by phone Friday afternoon. "I just cannot tell you (the reason)."

Guthrie, 76, came to town less than a year ago. His one-year anniversary would have been Tuesday.

Guthrie sent a three-sentence resignation letter to Gov. Brian Sandoval at about 2:30 p.m. Friday. The letter said he was honored to have served as superintendent of Nevada and expressed regret over his resignation.

“Thank you for having given me the opportunity to serve this state,” Guthrie said in the letter.

Sandoval issued a press release just minutes after Guthrie's announcement.

“Dr. Guthrie moved to Nevada and helped the state transition from an elected to an appointed Superintendent,” Sandoval said in a statement. “I thank him for his service to our great state and I wish him the best.”

Sandoval named Deputy Superintendent Rorie Fitzpatrick as interim superintendent. A process for appointing a permanent superintendent is forthcoming, Sandoval's press release said.

The state superintendent is appointed by the governor and reports directly to the governor. There is no term limit.

Guthrie was chosen among five candidates for the superintendent position in March 2012. Previously, the state superintendent was chosen by the state school board, but a new law gave that power to the governor.


Guthrie became a somewhat divisive figure in an otherwise cautious administration. He was known for his bluntness and criticized for a less-than-eloquent delivery of the governor's education agenda.

During his tenure as state superintendent of public instruction, Guthrie came under fire for his school reform proposals as well as controversial comments to the public and media.

Guthrie's proposals to end automatic teacher raises, implement a new teacher evaluation system and expand charter schools were met with immense pushback from teachers union.

Guthrie also made public gaffes, most notably when he told the Reno Gazette-Journal that the Washoe County School District "looks like a dream" when compared with Clark County."

In a subsequent interview, Guthrie told the Las Vegas Sun that the governor's chief of staff called Guthrie the next morning and told him to "kiss and make up" with former Clark County Schools Superintendent Dwight Jones. Apparently, Jones was "so mad at me, he couldn't even say my name," Guthrie said.

Perhaps Guthrie's most controversial comments came when he recently suggested to state lawmakers that a high quality teacher in the classroom could handle large class sizes.

The superintendent's comments — perceived by many to be against class size reduction — were derided by many legislators, who argued class sizes, especially in Clark County, were too high. His class size comments sparked a couple of demonstrations by teachers union members in the past several weeks.

Ruben Murillo, president of the Clark County Education Association, said he was not surprised by Guthrie's resignation in light of his recent comments.

"Superintendent Guthrie was a bit out of step with reality in terms of class size reduction," Murillo said. "I kind of had a feeling that his wouldn't be reappointed, but didn't think he would resign."


Guthrie’s resignation comes less than a month after Clark County Schools Superintendent Dwight Jones announced his resignation. Jones said he was leaving the nation’s fifth-largest school district to tend to his elderly mother in Dallas.

Both Jones and Guthrie were polarizing school reform figures who brought significant changes to Nevada. Guthrie and Jones were in the middle of implementing a new statewide school rating system when they announced their resignation.

Their resignations also came about halfway through a critical Legislative session where a proposal to change the state's funding formula for local school districts is being hotly debated.

While Democrats often criticized Guthrie, Sen. Debbie Smith, D-Reno, said his departure is troubling.

"I'm distressed to see a change in leadership midsession," said Smith, who chairs the influential Senate Finance Committee. "We have a lot of work to do, and we need strong leadership from in our state, and I certainly wish Dr. Guthrie well."

She said legislators are halfway through the session, and they'll be looking at the state education budget without consistency in leadership.

Smith said Fitzpatrick is a competent replacement for Guthrie.

"She's a walking encyclopedia of information, but how's she going to do it all?" Smith said. "She's great, but we still have one less set of hands and one less brain to help us."

Guthrie's departure only compounds the lack of clarity and instability of leadership that has confronted legislators as they began to craft education policy this year.

Legislators had often clashed with Guthrie, most pointedly on the issue of class-size reduction. Guthrie, however, maintained to legislators that he was only advocating for the governor's positions.

"They just shot the messenger," said a source at the Legislature familiar with the state's education system.


Gary Peck, the executive director of the Nevada State Education Association, said he did not know Guthrie's resignation was in the works. Despite their disagreements over the past year, Peck wished Guthrie well in his future endeavors.

"While we didn't always agree with Dr. Guthrie on important education policy and reform issues, we wish him well," Peck said. "We look forward to working with Rorie Fitzpatrick."

The Clark County School District spokeswoman Amanda Fulkerson said the state's largest school system will continue to work with the Legislature and the governor to advocate for its priorities.

"We wish Mr. Guthrie well and will continue to work well with the (state) Department of education team and interim Superintendent Fitzpatrick," Fulkerson said in a statement.

Clark County School Board president Carolyn Edwards said Guthrie didn't have enough time to implement his ideas for changing Nevada's education system.

"He had a huge learning curve to overcome," Edwards — a former state school board president — said. "Nevada is a very diverse state with different challenges. (Guthrie) was still figuring out all the issues.

"It's unfortunate that our first (governor-)appointed superintendent had such a short time," she continued. "The timing (of his resignation) is awkward."


On Friday, Guthrie said he hoped the best for Nevada's struggling education system, which has the worst graduation rate among states, according to the federal government.

If the state continues with his reform efforts, Nevada children "will have a better opportunity to succeed," Guthrie said, adding he has no immediate plans for his career future.

Guthrie was previously director of education policy studies at the George W. Bush Institute and served as an education scholar at Vanderbilt University and the University of Southern California. He has consulted with various governments overseas in Africa, Australia, Asia and South America, as well as authored 20 books and more than 200 scholarly articles.

Guthrie was aware of mounting pressure from his critics. In a February interview with the Las Vegas Sun's editorial board, Guthrie hinted at the precarious nature of his position as the executor of Sandoval's school reform efforts. Sandoval's press secretary did not return a call for comment on Friday afternoon.

"I told (the governor) once that if he fired me, I'd leave the way I came in," Guthrie said. "Fired with enthusiasm."

Join the Discussion:

Check this out for a full explanation of our conversion to the LiveFyre commenting system and instructions on how to sign up for an account.

Full comments policy

Previous Discussion: 12 comments so far…

Comments are moderated by Las Vegas Sun editors. Our goal is not to limit the discussion, but rather to elevate it. Comments should be relevant and contain no abusive language. Comments that are off-topic, vulgar, profane or include personal attacks will be removed. Full comments policy. Additionally, we now display comments from trusted commenters by default. Those wishing to become a trusted commenter need to verify their identity or sign in with Facebook Connect to tie their Facebook account to their Las Vegas Sun account. For more on this change, read our story about how it works and why we did it.

Only trusted comments are displayed on this page. Untrusted comments have expired from this story.

  1. Is there any doubt now that the "public school system train has completely derailed" in this state folks? Why are these supposed "best and brightest" abandoning ship so quickly after arriving here? Apparently, there is a wealth of information that is being withheld regarding this latest resignation. The public deserves to be told the truth about our public schools!

  2. The Mighty Teachers Union Scores Another Victory!

  3. another high ranking administrator leaving?
    Obviously something is up with all these guys leaving under dubious circumstances

  4. And how much money did we pay this guy?

    And how much is his golden parachute?

  5. Two mistakes gone in a week: Jones and Guthrie. Good news for our children!

  6. I've read that a lot of educators backed both Guthrie and Jones, who have both recently left, in the idea department.

    Something is ripe if people leave like this and so close together. My question is, why not be more transparent about why you're leaving? Why not come out and give a reason. Fishy.

  7. The handwriting is on the wall, folks.

    If Nevada Lawmakers continue to not adequately and sustainably FUND education, this type of behavior will continue, and the giant sucking sound of educators leaving the state or leaving the profession will be the one shot heard around the world.

    Also aggrevating this problem, is the fact that until vital partners (parents and students) in education are made accountable and responsible, educational changes for the good will be minimal.

    A parent is the first and lifelong teacher of their child.

    Nevada Lawmakers need to put ENforcement teeth in the taxpayer funded, yearly administered, PARENT/TEACHER/STUDENT INVOLVEMENT ACCORD. In the last Nevada State Legislative Session, Lawmakers made administrators and teachers accountable and responsible via the new evaluations.

    Districts throughout the State of Nevada, failed to follow through on creating performance pay models due this session. Oh, by the way, this is NOT a teacher/union failure to perform...this is a result of those in LEADERSHIP positions, who are not too interested in admitting this wrong doing and failure to follow a directive from the State Legislature. The 76th Nevada Legislative Session mandated the performance pay model, but DID NOT FUND IT. Somehow, that money is going to come from somewhere...maybe via the frozen teacher salaries, so the school districts can "build their reserves back" towards paying for this mandated performance pay no one knows anything about. GEZ. Think about it.

    We simply cannot continue to rush Lawmakers in crafting laws without thinking things through. Gone are the days where folks "volunteer" their time to help their employer and jobsite, as the workplace has inadvertantly turned into a hostile environment pitting those who SHOULD be working together, against one another in the name of keeping one's job. This is not a good way to run a "people business". This is just one of the "unintended consequences" of the hasty crafting of laws. No one should have a job where each day they wonder if they are a "target" for some administrator, or by their own peers, but it is happening, and it is not nice.

    The world has changed. I grew up believing in teamwork, but that is fast disappearing in today's culture. Today, it is about "top down management". We are witnessing how that all is working out.

    Blessings and Peace,

  8. By age 76 most people that have the means are long retired.
    Maybe he had an epiphany that there may not be many good years left and it's past time to enjoy some freedom and a casual lifestyle.
    I made that decision at 55 and have never regretted it.

  9. This sentence would explain it all.


    Guthrie was previously director of education policy studies at the George W. Bush Institute


  10. By age 76 most people that have the means are long retired.
    Maybe he had an epiphany that there may not be many good years left and it's past time to enjoy some freedom and a casual lifestyle.
    I made that decision at 55 and have never regretted it.
    I would agree. I didn't see his age. Long past time to smell the roses.

  11. The Governor needs to show some leadership and tell the teachers and union that it's past time they, the teachers, participate in shared sacrifice that the rest of the economy has had forced upon it. Teachers are so quick to jump on anyone and everyone who doesn't idolize their "efforts." Let's get some results and forget about "motives." K-12 is over funded. We NEED longer school days and longer school years--for the sake of educating our children. PUT TEACHERS ON FULL TIME, year round and stop the media circus.

  12. Commenter Roberta Anderson stated, "We NEED longer school days and longer school years--for the sake of educating our children. PUT TEACHERS ON FULL TIME, year round and stop the media circus."

    While we are at it, let's also PUT STUDENTS AND THEIR PARENT ON FULL TIME, year round responsibility and accountability as well, to stop the negative results we have been witnessing. All parties involved should be focused on doing what is best. I never had a problem with that, nor ever will. For it all to work, ALL parties need to participate and do their best.

    Blessings and Peace,