Retired teachers’ health plan pact reached
The goal is to keep tenured educators on the job
Wed, May 7, 2008 (2 a.m.)
Sun Archives
- To keep teachers in classrooms (2-28-2008)
- Retired teachers’ insurance in state high court’s hands (2-3-2008)
- Teachers grab extra incentive to retire (7-25-2007)
Beyond the Sun
After months of haggling, the Clark County School District and the teachers union have a tentative agreement to offer health insurance to the district’s retired educators.
The plan is designed to encourage experienced teachers to stay on the job and to reassure rookies that they will have insurance when their retirement dates arrive. Subsidized health insurance for retirees also would be a useful lure in the district’s recruiting tackle box.
The Teachers Health Trust phased out its retiree coverage in 2003. The district’s teachers were sent instead to the state’s health insurance plan. In an effort to prevent the state plan from being swamped by retirees’ medical care costs, the 2007 Legislature changed the rules, and one result of those changes was that Clark County teachers who retire after Sept. 1 will no longer be eligible for state health insurance.
The change had the district fearing that many of its most experienced teachers would opt to retire early to qualify for the subsidized coverage. A mass exodus was expected in the coming months because summer is when teacher retirements typically spike.
The district has long struggled to retain its veteran teachers. Roughly half of the district’s teachers have fewer than five years’ experience, and 50 percent of new hires typically leave within five years.
The teachers who are “here for a career, not a pit stop ... need to reap those benefits when they leave,” said John Jasonek, executive director of the Clark County Education Association.
Members of the association are to vote on the proposed agreement May 21.
The proposal isn’t without problems. A key issue is its lack of “portability,” said Judith Hamblin, president of the Clark County Retired Education Association. Like the Teachers Health Trust insurance for active employees, the retiree plan is limited to Southern Nevada providers.
“What happens if you want to retire to Utah, or your health fails and you need to move in with a relative back East?” Hamblin said. “You’re up a creek.”
Clark County Schools Superintendent Walt Rulffes and Jasonek both said they are aware of the plan’s geographic limitations, and there is an effort under way to offer retirees an out-of-state option.
Some younger teachers might balk at deductions from their pay for the program. Under the proposal, active teachers would see an additional $15 deducted from each paycheck — $360 annually from each teacher — to help offset the cost.
Donald Backner, who is one of the district’s five New Teachers of the Year for 2007-08, said he would have to see the specifics of the proposal before deciding whether or not he would support it.
For many younger teachers, “retirement is so far away,” said Backner, who teaches fifth grade at Dusty Dickens Elementary School. “I’m just thinking about the kids I have right now, not about health care.”
Under the proposed plan retired teachers with a minimum of 10 years on the job would have the same health benefits as their active colleagues. The monthly premiums would depend on the individual’s years of service. A teacher who works 25 years would have 53 percent of the premium’s cost subsidized. At 30 years, the subsidy would jump to 68 percent.
With that tiering, “there’s not much incentive to leave at 29 years,” Rulffes said. “With that kind of dramatic increase (in the subsidy), we’re hopeful people will want to keep working.”
Additionally, some state and district funding allocated to the Teachers’ Health Trust — which operates independent of the union — will be redirected toward the new retiree plan.
Based on that formula, the plan has a “conservative shelf life” of 10 years without needing an additional funding source, Jasonek said.
The projected “real cost” of the monthly premium is $1,169, Jasonek said. The goal is that retirees will pay less than $500 a month. A retired teacher with 30 years’ tenure and 450 unused sick days would have a 75 percent subsidy. That would make the individual’s monthly cost $292.
Discussion: 4 comments so far…
Post a comment
- Most Read
- Discussed
- Editors’ Picks
- Las Vegas man killed in two-car collision
- Down and out in Las Vegas
- Take Five: Ultimate Fighting Championship 86, Jackson vs. Griffin
- Art theft! Lawsuits! Spielberg!
- It’s fun, it’s for Wii, just don’t call it ‘beer pong’
- Planet Hollywood slips in a promising title bout
- Henderson college’s grad rate disappoints
- Holiday shotgun blasts leads to police standoff, arrests
- American Idols Live: Archuleta wins the night
- Fire danger leads to Red Flag Warning for Las Vegas; temperatures headed to 108
Blogs
Joe Brown
American Idols Live: Archuleta wins the night
Sports: Upon Further Review
UFC 86: Presser
UFC: The Gov was here
Bloggity, Bloggity, Bloggity
Observations from Saturday’s NASCAR Coke Zero 400 at Daytona International Speedway (7 Comments)
Sports: Upon Further Review
UFC 86: Forrest Wins, Forrest wins, Forrest wins (1 Comment)
UFC: Cote wins; it's time
UFC: Near the end
UFC 86: Stevenson wins
Calendar
Terry Fator
The multi-talented Terry Fator comes to the Las Vegas Hilton for three shows in one weekend. ( Las Vegas Hilton)
- Noche Nortena (7 p.m. to 11:59 p.m.)
- Whiskey Bar Un-Plugged (9 p.m.)
- Damon Wayans (8 p.m.)
- Club Tequila (7 p.m.)
The Sun
Locally owned and independent for more than 50 years.

Thank you, but no thank you. This proposal is definitely wrong for teachers. There is a very simple solution to this retirement problem facing teachers. It's so simple that I am sure every teacher would simply say -- "Do it." Dissolve the Teacher's Health Trust currently enforced by CCEA. Return it to CCSD. In so doing, every teacher -- newbie to 30+ year veteran could be covered with the state plan for no more than $80.00 a month.
If the CCEA echelon won't do this, then one would have to question -- Why not? There might be some fraud going on at CCEA headquarters. And if that is the case why give CCEA close to $8M a year to fund a program that ultimately "screws" teacher retirees with a plan that can only be used in Southern Nevada after that teacher retires????
I hope teachers see that this proposal only benefits the brass at CCEA Central.
No way. It will start at $15.00 a paycheck, and it will be up every year. NO WAY.
And you will be forced to retire in Las Vegas. NO WAY@
Ok, so what do you two suggest? All of the information I have gathered would seem to indicate that the health system from the State is unreliable at best, and that it is a sure gamble that within a certain number of iterations it will be completely off the books. Which would send us back to the drawing board. This, by the way, is a problem being faced all over the country, not just the CCSD. So again I ask, if the PEBP optioin is likely eventually off of the table, what do you do? Give me a some soultions if you think this next proposal is so lousy.
You are wrong about the sate plan. It's as good as gold. The CCEA plan is fraught with problems from the get-go. I, for one, do not trust Jasonek with money. There are too many times that he has done under-handed deals with CCSD at the expense of teachers. He will definitely refuse to do independent audits as he has done with the Health Trust. His plan will go belly-up after a a year to 18 months, and he will have pocketed $12M, and no one will be able to "pin" anything on him and his elite board of executives. If you don't think this can happen, ask any support staff person who saw this happen with their health Trust. They went to bed the night before, and lo and behold the next morning -- no health trust. In fact this group had an internal audit (how cozy) a week before this event, and that auditor found their health trust was sound. What happened to the officers of that health trust? Well, a few of them became administrators (yes, administrators) for CCSD. One of them is FJ. You can figure that out by going to the Crystal Palace on Sahara and asking for this person.