Las Vegas Sun

March 29, 2024

Blog

A Supreme Ruling

What's the point of taking great care to elect judges if lawmakers, in an attempt to pander to shell-shocked voters, tie the hands of the judiciary with laws that rob the bench of its discretion? That was the case during the tough-on-crime, truth-in-sentencing days of the '90s. Empowered by catchy mantras like "adult time for adult crime," legislatures throughout the country passed laws requiring blanket treatment of juveniles charged with certain violent offenses.

Much has changed since then, including scientific advances that reveal the decision-making judgment centers of the brain are not fully developed until the mid-20s, especially in males. Yet adult prosecution of minors, a course of action historically reserved for the worst offenders, is all too routine in Clark County. Juvenile offenders are regularly "certified" as adults, not necessarily because the alleged offense warrants it, but as one prosecutor told us today, because the District Attorney does not want to mix hardened 17-year-olds with youngsters who may still be ripe for rehabilitation.

But is a lack of state resources reason to thrust the older child into the adult system, when he may have benefited from juvenile court? And are attorneys, who often advise juveniles to opt for adult court in hopes of probation rather than a lengthy stay in a juvenile facility, robbing their young clients of potentially valuable services available to juvenile offenders?

Tonight Jon talks with the attorneys who argued against one another before the Nevada Supreme Court, which last week tossed out the state's law requiring that certain juveniles be tried as adults. The law allowed the offenders to remain in the juvenile system by admitting their offense was related to an emotional, behavioral or drug problem. The court says requiring an admission of guilt in juvenile court in order to avoid adult prosecution is unconstitutional.

Join the Discussion:

Check this out for a full explanation of our conversion to the LiveFyre commenting system and instructions on how to sign up for an account.

Full comments policy