Las Vegas Sun

July 2, 2015

Currently: 103° — Complete forecast | Log in | Create an account

carson city:

Court rules Legislature’s $62 million grab unconstitutional


Sam Morris

At one time, the Clean Water Coalition had planned a pipeline that would have crossed this stretch of the Las Vegas Wash to expel treated wastewater into the deeper depths of greater Lake Mead. However, the CWC mothballed that project and the Nevada Legislature took $62 million allocated for it.

Updated Thursday, May 26, 2011 | 2:28 p.m.

CARSON CITY – The Nevada Supreme Court has ruled the Legislature's $62 million grab from the Clean Water Coalition in Clark County was unconstitutional.

The unanimous ruling punches another hole in the already slim state budget. The money had been included in Gov. Brian Sandoval’s spending plan.

To help solve the state’s budget problems, the 2010 special session of the Legislature passed a law to require the coalition to turn over $62 million to the state.

The court’s decision prompts two big questions at the local government level: Will sewer ratepayers get a refund since the Clean Water Coalition has been dissolved and doesn’t need the money? And should local governments and schools start worrying about more budget cuts, since the state will be looking to fill that $62 million hole?

Ratepayers from four jurisdictions paid into the Clean Water Coalition — Las Vegas, Clark County, North Las Vegas and Henderson. If the $62 million is refunded to those jurisdictions, spokespeople for each governmental body said the county could expect around $30 million, Henderson about $8 million, North Las Vegas about $6 million and Las Vegas close to $20 million. The exact figures are not yet known.

As to whom will get that refund, at the county level the decision will be made by Clark County commissioners.

Based on a recent decision by the commission to refund some other Clean Water Coalition money to taxpayers, and because the political consequences of keeping the $31 million could be dire, it’s unlikely it will do anything except refund the money.

“I think that’s safe to say,” said commission Vice Chairman Steve Sisolak.

There’s no telling what the other local governments will do with their smaller refunds. There’s also no clue as to whether the high court’s decision will lead state lawmakers to take more money from local governments to prop up the state budget.

County Commissioner Larry Brown, chairman of the Clean Water Coalition board, welcomed the court’s decision. He also said county staff and commissioners want “to be part of the solution” to the state’s budget crisis and will continue talking to lawmakers until the end of the session.

In addition, Don Burnette, Clark County manager, said county “are very committed to working with the Legislature to resolve their issues without making the problems worse.”

The coalition collected money from residents in Clark County to design and build an $850 million system to carry treated sewage into Lake Mead. The project was suspended in December 2009 due to the economic decline and lack of growth in Southern Nevada. The coalition is now studying how the treated effluent might affect Lake Mead.

In a unanimous opinion written by Justice James Hardesty, the court said the Legislature has “considerable lawmaking authority” under the Nevada Constitution. But the court said there are restrictions on that power.

The court said the Legislature is prohibited from enacting local and special laws for the assessment and collection of taxes for the state. The state constitution requires laws to be general and uniform throughout the state, the court said.

According to the ruling, the Legislature violated the constitutional requirement when it singled out the Clean Water Coalition and took money collected only in Clark County.

The ruling reverses the decision of District Judge David Barker, who ruled in favor of the Legislature.

The coalition was created under an agreement with the Clark County Water Reclamation District and the cities of Henderson, Las Vegas and North Las Vegas. Those local governments collected money from residents on their sewer bills and turned it over to the coalition.

Joining the water coalition in a lawsuit against the state were the M Resort, Ovation Development Corporation, Jet Hangars, Sun City Summerlin Community Association and the Henderson Chamber of Commerce.

The 2010 law that required the water collation to turn over the $62 million said the money would be put into the state’s general fund for unlimited use. The coalition never surrendered the money during the legal battle.

The court said the act of the Legislature violated three sections of the Nevada Constitution, “which prohibits local and special laws that assess and collect taxes for state purposes.”

Hardesty, in the 32-page opinion, said the court agrees the state had a statewide budget crisis but the Legislature couldn't single out the Clean Water Coalition to help solve it.

Join the Discussion:

Check this out for a full explanation of our conversion to the LiveFyre commenting system and instructions on how to sign up for an account.

Full comments policy

Previous Discussion: 13 comments so far…

Comments are moderated by Las Vegas Sun editors. Our goal is not to limit the discussion, but rather to elevate it. Comments should be relevant and contain no abusive language. Comments that are off-topic, vulgar, profane or include personal attacks will be removed. Full comments policy. Additionally, we now display comments from trusted commenters by default. Those wishing to become a trusted commenter need to verify their identity or sign in with Facebook Connect to tie their Facebook account to their Las Vegas Sun account. For more on this change, read our story about how it works and why we did it.

Only trusted comments are displayed on this page. Untrusted comments have expired from this story.

  1. This doesn't suprise me as both houses are run by the dems. They think everyones money should be theirs.

  2. Raise taxes on the foreign mining corporations that get so many write-offs that they are paid WITH the taxes of Nevada's working families to mine here! Call your legislator at 1-800-978-2878 and demand that the gravy train for the foreign mining corporations paid for by our taxes end! its time for them to pay their fair share!

  3. "The Nevada Supreme Court has ruled that a $62 million grab by the Legislature last year from the Clean Water Coalition in Clark County was unconstitutional."


    Unfortunately the state's attempt at theft is nothing new --

    "[The law] has placed the collective force in the service of those who wish to traffic, without risk, and without scruple, in the persons, the liberty, and the property of others; it has converted plunder into a right, that it may protect it, and lawful defense into a crime, that it may punish it." -- Frederic Bastiat, 1850 "The Law"

  4. More to the point, money from us in Clark County was going to the STATE. Considering that so many northern Nevadans hate government, it's only fair that we close down all government outside of Las Vegas and Reno, and let them enjoy having no schools or roads, and we'll take the money here.

  5. "This doesn't suprise me as both houses are run by the dems. They think everyones money should be theirs."

    Ah, if only Commonsense101, aka Justin, could read:

    "That money had been included in Gov. Brian Sandoval's spending plan."

    That's right, the leader of the GOP in Nevada tried to violate the Nevada constitution.

    Will the Nevada GOP try to impeach him? Will the tea party riot?

  6. The money had been taken Last year before the governor had even been elected. Putting funds that the legislature had on hand into the budget isn't the issue.

    Sandovol had no part in taking the money.

  7. "Sandovol had no part in taking the money."

    Sandoval wrote his own budget, and had full authority to refuse those funds, Justin.

  8. Michael - I am with you. The folks in rural Nevada, for the most part are a bunch of anti-government lunatics like Sharron Angle. I think they should learn to live within their budget and quit relying on everyone else in the State to support them.

  9. "Sandoval wrote his own budget, and had full authority to refuse those funds, Justin."

    If ur gona blame the man for using funds that the legislature and the board that tells him how much money to use said he had well there is just no fixing you.

    The governor does not make the budget. He only makes a recomendation. Bet the dems used that money too. Again my point is that the money was stolen by the dems in the first place last year. That happend when they finaly realized we didn't need to make lake mead a potty pond anymore. Instead of giving it back they decided it was theirs now.

    Again maybe he should have thought to exclude those funds...but he didn't steal them. That was the dems.

  10. As I recall...

    I guess his "plan" to raid & steal every nickel from every nook and cranny in Clark County to put together his SHODDY AND ILL-CONCEIVED budget "plan" is not so darn clever after all.
    Hey B.S., better get on the phone with R&R Partners and your Law Firm Jones Vargas and see how them good ol' boys want you to proceed!

  11. >>The governor does not make the budget. He only makes a recomendation.<<


    The governor writes the entire budget and submits it to the legislature. He does NOT make a "recomendation".

    Now go read the Nevada constitution, learn how the system of government in this state functions, and please, for the love of pete, USE SPELL AND GRAMMAR CHECK! Going through your posts is like reading written Tea Party rants on crack!

  12. Thank you, William.

    Justin, Nevada state constitution declares that the Governor is required to submit an Executive budget no later than 14 days after the start of the legislative session. This is Nevada Civics 101.

  13. omg you're telling me that the governor does not know basic government accounting. Govt accounting 101- state and local govts have to set up funds, those funds unless it is the general fund cannot be used for anything else except what they were designated for. If funds e.g water fund is used for anything but water it is illegal. I learned that in school. So you're telling me that the education in Nevada is so bad that the governor doesn't know basic govt accounting? wow