Las Vegas Sun

April 19, 2015

Currently: 73° — Complete forecast | Log in | Create an account


Lack of competition is bad news for ratepayers

As CEO of a company that owns two gas-fired power plants in North Las Vegas, I want to invest in the Nevada economy. I want to hire contractors, pay taxes and provide as many jobs as possible. But if Senate Bill 123 is signed into law, those things will become difficult, if not impossible. Worse, companies like mine may go out of business.

The headlines say that SB123 will retire coal plants and replace them with natural gas and renewables. But lost in translation is how this will be accomplished.

Buried in the fine print of the bill is a provision to remove public oversight over NV Energy, effectively making it a pure monopoly. As a result, companies like mine, which put competitive pressure on the monopoly, will be pushed out of the market — and your rates will go up.

Some background on the power industry helps explain the problem. Before electricity gets to your house, it passes through three phases: generation (where it’s created); transmission (where it’s moved); and distribution (where it’s delivered).

Transmission and distribution require enormous amounts of capital, so they’re typically controlled by utilities. But generation can be provided at lower costs. This allows nonutility generators, known as independent power producers, to bid against utilities for the right to generate electricity. As in any bidding situation, the low bid usually wins. That, in turn, keeps prices down for ratepayers.

But SB123 changes that. According to the bill, 550 megawatts of natural gas generation must be owned by the utility. In other words, the utility can set prices wherever it wishes, and the PUC has no choice but to accept them. The PUC cannot solicit other bids, nor can it demand cheaper alternatives. It can’t even tell the utility to consider using existing plants rather than building brand new, expensive, redundant ones.

And here’s the kicker: The more money the utility spends, the more it makes. So there’s absolutely no reason for the utility to submit anything other than the most expensive proposal. It’s the opposite of competitive bidding.

My company’s plant has provided electricity to Nevadans since 2004. We employ 19 highly skilled workers. A greenhouse on our site produces up to 100,000 cucumbers per day and employs an additional 140 people. We have paid tens of millions of dollars in salaries, taxes, and payments for goods and services over the years. We are proud to do business in Nevada.

However, next January our contract expires. Normally, we would submit a bid to renew it. But SB123 bans us from even offering a proposal to fill 550 megawatts of identified needs. Without competition from us and others like us, the utility becomes a monopoly. And as any economist will tell you, monopolies raise prices. Always have, always will.

SB123 now sits on Gov. Brian Sandoval’s desk, and all indications are he will sign it. I wish he wouldn’t. But if he does, let’s hope that SB123 is implemented in a way that gives independent power producers and ratepayers the benefit of a fair, open and competitive process.

Mo Klefeker is president and CEO of Southwest Generation, an independent power producer headquartered in Denver that owns and operates two gas-fired power plants in North Las Vegas.

Join the Discussion:

Check this out for a full explanation of our conversion to the LiveFyre commenting system and instructions on how to sign up for an account.

Full comments policy

Previous Discussion: 2 comments so far…

Comments are moderated by Las Vegas Sun editors. Our goal is not to limit the discussion, but rather to elevate it. Comments should be relevant and contain no abusive language. Comments that are off-topic, vulgar, profane or include personal attacks will be removed. Full comments policy. Additionally, we now display comments from trusted commenters by default. Those wishing to become a trusted commenter need to verify their identity or sign in with Facebook Connect to tie their Facebook account to their Las Vegas Sun account. For more on this change, read our story about how it works and why we did it.

Only trusted comments are displayed on this page. Untrusted comments have expired from this story.

  1. The government in partnership with public utilities pushes its own energy agenda at taxpayers' expense, as the columnist illustrates. This leads to the following proven results: Huge public debt and deficits for government energy subsidies; less private investment which is squeezed out by the government spending in alternative energy research and development; and less government funds to allocate on more pressing and imminent health, education, and societal needs. Usually at higher prices for energy to the consumers.

    Carmine D

  2. Thank the Legislature for the NVE/Buffett entitlement act.

    And don't think we would still be tied to coal if if hadn't passed - we wouldn't - NVE had already admitted Reid Gardner and coal no longer made business sense. The legislature and some of the enviro community fell over themselves giving NVE gifts, when in reality the battle had already been won.